Current:Home > MyNRA can sue ex-NY official it says tried to blacklist it after Parkland shooting, Supreme Court says -TradeWise
NRA can sue ex-NY official it says tried to blacklist it after Parkland shooting, Supreme Court says
View
Date:2025-04-17 21:06:33
WASHINGTON (AP) — A unanimous Supreme Court on Thursday cleared the way for a National Rifle Association lawsuit against a former New York state official over claims she pressured companies to blacklist it following the deadly 2018 school shooting in Parkland, Florida.
Giving the NRA a new chance to prove its case, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that “the critical takeaway is that the First Amendment prohibits government officials from wielding their power selectively to punish or suppress speech.”
The NRA said ex-New York state Department of Financial Services Superintendent Maria Vullo violated its free-speech rights during her investigation of NRA-endorsed insurance policies. The group had been working with insurance companies to offer its members Carry Guard policies that covered losses caused by firearms, even when the insured person intentionally killed or hurt somebody. Critics have called the policies “murder insurance.”
In an unusual alignment, the NRA was represented in the case by the American Civil Liberties Union, and the Biden administration argued some of its claims should go forward.
“This is a landmark victory for the NRA and all who care about our First Amendment freedom,” NRA attorney William A. Brewer III said, accusing New York government officials of abusing their power to silence the group.
The Supreme Court ruling favoring the NRA, which is based in Fairfax, Virginia, reverses a lower-court decision tossing out the gun rights group’s lawsuit against Vullo. The decision means the NRA’s lawsuit can go forward, but it does not decide the merits of the claim. It also should not be read to shield the NRA and other advocacy groups from regulation, Sotomayor said.
But, she wrote, the NRA’s complaint “plausibly alleges that Vullo threatened to wield her power against those refusing to aid her campaign to punish the NRA’s gun-promotion advocacy. If true, that violates the First Amendment.”
Vullo argued that she rightly investigated NRA-endorsed insurance policies. She said she did speak out about the risks of doing business with gun groups but didn’t exert any improper pressure on companies, many of which were distancing themselves from the NRA on their own at the time.
The NRA said Vullo leveraged the state investigation into the legality of NRA-endorsed insurance products to pressure insurance companies, saying she would go easier on them if they cut ties with the group.
The products clearly violated state law, Vullo countered, including by covering intentional acts and criminal defense costs. The probe started before the Parkland massacre, which left 17 people dead, and the insurance providers ultimately agreed to pay multimillion-dollar fines.
Vullo also sent out guidance letters to banks and insurance companies warning about the “reputational risks” of working with the NRA. The NRA said her words had significant sway because of her position and several companies cut ties with the group, costing it millions of dollars in revenue.
Vullo said the letters were evenhanded, and her attorney argued that letting the lawsuit go forward would improperly muzzle public officials.
___
Associated Press writer Mark Sherman contributed to this story.
___
Follow the AP’s coverage of the U.S. Supreme Court at https://apnews.com/hub/us-supreme-court.
veryGood! (5373)
Related
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- Biden administration urges colleges to pursue racial diversity without affirmative action
- Small Kansas newspaper says co-owner, 98, collapsed and died after police raid
- A central Kansas police force comes under constitutional criticism after raiding a newspaper
- Current, future North Carolina governor’s challenge of power
- Two witnesses to testify Tuesday before Georgia grand jury investigating Trump
- See how one volunteer group organized aid deliveries after fire decimates Lahaina
- The Taliban are entrenched in Afghanistan after 2 years of rule. Women and girls pay the price
- Israel lets Palestinians go back to northern Gaza for first time in over a year as cease
- Survival of Wild Rice Threatened by Climate Change, Increased Rainfall in Northern Minnesota
Ranking
- Meet first time Grammy nominee Charley Crockett
- 21-year-old woman dies after falling 300 feet at Rocky Mountain National Park
- 'No time to grieve': Maui death count could skyrocket, leaving many survivors traumatized
- A landmark case: In first-of-its-kind Montana climate trial, judge rules for youth activists
- Chuck Scarborough signs off: Hoda Kotb, Al Roker tribute legendary New York anchor
- 3-year-old migrant girl dies aboard bus headed from Texas to Chicago
- Drugs and prostitution in the office: 'Telemarketers' doc illuminates world you don't know
- Rescued baby walrus getting round-the-clock cuddles as part of care regimen dies in Alaska
Recommendation
California DMV apologizes for license plate that some say mocks Oct. 7 attack on Israel
Maui wildfire crews continue to fight flare-ups in Lahaina and inland, as death toll rises past 90
Baltimore Orioles OF Cedric Mullins robs game-tying home run, hits game-winning home run
A former Georgia police chief is now teaching middle school
'Most Whopper
Inmate dead after incarceration at Georgia jail under federal investigation
Jury acquits 1 of 2 brothers charged in 2013 slaying in north central Indiana
3 Maryland vacationers killed and 3 more hurt in house fire in North Carolina’s Outer Banks